Proposition 128 – What Does it Mean?

October 17, 2024
Written by: Ashley Furst, Director of Business Development & Community Engagement

In November 2024, Colorado voters will have the opportunity to decide on Proposition 128, an initiative commonly referred to as “Truth in Sentencing.” This proposal seeks to extend the percentage of time that incarcerated individuals must serve before becoming eligible for parole, increasing the minimum from 75% to 85% for certain violent crimes. Proposition 128 raises important questions regarding its potential impact on the state’s criminal justice system, correctional staffing, financial resources, and overall public safety.

Understanding the Increase from 75% to 85

Currently, individuals are eligible for parole after serving 75% of their sentence. To be granted parole, they must demonstrate to the parole board that they understand the harm they caused and have a plan to reintegrate safely into the community. Parole is only granted if the board believes the individual meets these criteria, meaning those deemed unsafe remain incarcerated.

Raising the eligibility threshold to 85% would keep individuals incarcerated who the parole board would have previously considered safe for release. This unnecessary retention of people deemed safe will increase strain on correctional staff and impose significant additional costs on taxpayers.

Impact on Correctional Officers

One of the primary areas where Proposition 128 could have an effect is within Colorado’s correctional facilities. Currently, many of these facilities are operating with staff shortages, making recruitment and retention of correctional officers a significant challenge. Research has consistently shown that these shortages can contribute to higher stress, fatigue, and burnout among correctional officers. In turn, this may affect the safety and well-being of both staff and incarcerated individuals.

Extending incarceration periods through Proposition 128 would likely increase the prison population, potentially heightening the demand for correctional officers. Addressing workforce issues, such as recruitment, retention, and improving working conditions, may be essential considerations alongside any changes to sentencing laws.

Raising the eligibility threshold to 85% would keep individuals incarcerated who the parole board would have previously considered safe for release.

Fiscal Impact

The financial implications of Proposition 128 are significant. Colorado currently spends approximately $56,000 annually per person incarcerated. Extending incarceration times would increase this cost, placing further pressure on the state’s budget. According to estimates, the implementation of Proposition 128 could require an initial investment of over $150 million to expand prison capacity. Additionally, ongoing annual costs could rise by more than $56 million to accommodate the increased prison population.

These expenditures could have broader effects on state resources, as funds may need to be reallocated from other areas such as education, healthcare, or infrastructure. The potential financial strain comes at a time when Colorado is facing budget constraints, including a projected billion-dollar shortfall in 2025. Policymakers may need to weigh the long-term costs of extending incarceration periods against other priorities for state spending.

In an analysis by the state legislature, Proposition 128 is projected to increase state spending in two distinct ways. Initially, a one-time cost of $12,000 will be required to update the Department of Corrections’ case management system. Over time, the additional costs of maintaining longer prison sentences are estimated to range from $12 million to $28 million annually. These projections underscore the fiscal impact that may result from changes to the sentencing system. You can learn more in this fact sheet provided by Coloradans for Smart Justice.

Public Safety and Crime Reduction

Supporters of Proposition 128 argue that it will enhance public safety by ensuring that individuals convicted of violent crimes serve longer sentences. However, research on the relationship between sentence length and public safety outcomes is complex. Studies have found that extended incarceration does not always correlate with lower crime rates or reduced recidivism. In fact, programs that focus on rehabilitation, education, and reentry services have been shown to be more effective in reducing crime and promoting successful reintegration into society.

In Colorado, the parole board already holds the authority to assess the readiness of individuals for release, balancing public safety considerations with individual progress. Limiting earned time, as proposed in Proposition 128, may reduce incentives for incarcerated individuals to participate in rehabilitation programs, which have been linked to better post-release outcomes.

Crime rates in Colorado have shown recent declines. For example, data from 2023 indicates that many categories of violent crime were lower than in previous years. This suggests that focusing on evidence-based strategies, such as crime prevention and community support, may offer more effective solutions to enhancing public safety.

Conclusion

Proposition 128 raises important questions about Colorado’s approach to criminal justice, public safety, and fiscal responsibility. While the initiative seeks to extend incarceration periods for certain violent crimes, it also introduces challenges related to correctional staffing, state budgetary constraints, and the long-term effectiveness of extended sentences in reducing crime. As voters consider this initiative, it may be valuable to evaluate the balance between punitive measures and rehabilitative approaches in creating safer communities and ensuring responsible use of state resources.

Exploring investments in mental health services, reentry support, and crime prevention programs may offer alternative paths to achieving the goal of safer communities while addressing underlying issues within the criminal justice system.

At Breakthrough, we firmly believe that every person deserves the opportunity for redemption and access to second chances.

Our work is rooted in the conviction that rehabilitation, not prolonged punishment, is the key to building safer, more equitable communities. Rather than focusing on extending incarceration, we should be investing in programs that provide people with the tools they need to successfully reintegrate into society. Everyone, regardless of their past, should have access to the support and opportunities necessary to build a better future. 

More News

As we step into 2026, we want to take a moment to reflect on what we’ve accomplished — not as an organization alone, but with a…
For John—known to many as “Preacher”—a fair chance isn’t just about opportunity. It’s about humanity, healing, and the power of transformation. After 13 years of incarceration,…
Skip to content